Richard Allen Found Guilty in the Murders of Delphi Teen Girls Abigail Williams and Liberty German

A small Indiana community has been rocked by a long-awaited verdict in a chilling case that has captivated the nation for over seven years. Richard Allen, a former CVS pharmacy employee, was found guilty of the murders of two teenage girls, Abigail Williams, 13, and Liberty German, 14, who vanished during an afternoon hike on February 13, 2017.

On Monday, a jury convicted Allen on two counts of murder and two additional counts of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping. The verdict brings some closure to a community and two families who have been grieving for years, but also leaves behind a trail of disturbing details about how this tragedy unfolded.

Delphi Murders:Discovery and Investigation

The investigation into the disappearances of Abigail and Liberty began when the two girls were last seen hiking on the Monon High Bridge Trail in Delphi, Indiana, on February 13, 2017. Tragically, their bodies were found the following day, just off the trail. Despite initial efforts by law enforcement, the case remained unsolved for years. However, a breakthrough came in 2022.

In October 2022, after years of dead ends, Richard Allen was arrested. Authorities had been investigating Allen for some time, but what ultimately led to his arrest were key discoveries, including evidence that linked him to the crime scene and confessions made by Allen himself.

Two days after the girls’ bodies were found, Allen contacted authorities and claimed that he had been on the trail that afternoon. A retired state government worker who volunteered to help police uncovered paperwork in September 2022 showing that Allen had indeed reached out shortly after the discovery of the girls’ bodies, which led to his arrest.

This new information, along with an unspent bullet found at the crime scene that matched a handgun recovered from Allen’s home, further solidified his involvement.

Trial and Key Evidence

The trial of Richard Allen began on October 18, 2024, and lasted 17 days. The prosecution presented compelling evidence, including video footage taken by Liberty German on her phone just before her death. The footage shows a man walking across the Monon High Bridge, which ultimately became the key to identifying the “Bridge Guy.” This footage was taken just moments before the girls were killed, and it was later used to tie Richard Allen to the scene, as reported by NBC NEWS.

In addition to the video evidence, Allen’s confessions were crucial in the prosecution’s case. During a recorded jail phone call, with his wife, Allen allegedly admitted, “I did it. I killed Abby and Libby.” However, Allen’s defense team contended that these confessions were unreliable. They argued that Allen was experiencing a severe mental health crisis while in solitary confinement, and that his confessions were made under extreme stress, as reported by AP NEWS.

Nonetheless, the prosecution presented further evidence that undermined this argument. Dr. Monica Wala, Allen’s psychologist at the Westville Correctional Facility, testified that Allen had shared explicit details about the crime with her, including the claim that he slashed the girls’ throats and used tree branches to conceal their bodies.

According to Dr. Wala, Allen also told her that he abandoned his plans to sexually assault the girls when a van passed by, a detail that was confirmed by a local man, McLeland, who testified that he had been driving his van through the area at the time.

The Defense’s Argument

Throughout the trial, Allen’s defense team sought to present an alternative theory, suggesting that the murders might have been connected to a white nationalist group, the Odinists, who follow a pagan Norse religion. They posited that the killings could have been part of a ritualistic sacrifice. However, the judge ruled that there was no admissible evidence to support this theory, dismissing it entirely.

The defense also argued that Allen’s confessions were unreliable, citing his time in solitary confinement. A psychiatrist testified that prolonged isolation could lead to delirium and psychosis, causing a person to make false confessions. However, the jury found the defense’s arguments unconvincing, particularly given the detailed confessions and other corroborating evidence that tied Allen directly to the crime.

Legal Chaos and Setbacks in the Richard Allen Delphi Murder Case

The case was plagued with numerous legal challenges and controversies that complicated the investigation and trial. Prosecutors faced the daunting task of proving Allen’s guilt without physical evidence, such as DNA, fingerprints, or other forensic evidence that could directly link him to the crime scene. Instead, they relied on circumstantial evidence, including confessions made by Allen and the chilling cellphone footage of the “Bridge Guy,” allegedly showing Allen walking behind the victims shortly before their deaths.

Related|Muncie, Indiana Man Charged with Attempted Murder After Stabbing Ex-Girlfriend 20 Times

Adding to the complexity, the prosecution suffered several major setbacks. Among the most significant was the accidental loss of crucial police interviews spanning 70 days, as well as a report detailing the erasure of critical video footage that included key suspects in the investigation. These missteps, coupled with accusations of sealed evidence leaks, left the case embroiled in legal turmoil. Despite these hurdles, prosecutors argued that Allen’s confessions, including the phone call to his wife in which he allegedly said, “I did it. I killed Abby and Libby,” were compelling evidence of his involvement, as reported by Law & Crime.

On the other hand, Allen’s defense attorneys argued that the confessions were false, suggesting that prolonged solitary confinement and harassment by fellow inmates led Allen to falsely admit guilt. The defense team contended that the prosecution’s eagerness to solve the high-profile case led them to build a narrative around Allen’s statements, despite the lack of concrete physical evidence.

The Guilty Verdict for Richard Allen

The jury ultimately convicted Richard Allen of two counts of murder and two counts of murder while committing or attempting to commit kidnapping. The conviction followed emotional testimony from the prosecution, which underscored how the details provided by Allen could only have been known by the killer.

In their closing statements, the prosecution pointed out the critical importance of the van passing the crime scene. Prosecutor McLeland highlighted that this was a detail “only the killer would know.” Despite the defense’s attempt to discredit Allen’s confessions, the jury found the evidence compelling enough to return a guilty verdict.

The Impact on the Community

The guilty verdict provides a bittersweet sense of justice for the families of Abigail Williams and Liberty German, who have endured years of grief. The trial forced the small town of Delphi to relive the pain surrounding the girls’ tragic deaths, but the conviction offers a measure of closure to a long-running investigation.

While the verdict brings justice, it does not erase the trauma that the families and community have faced. The case remains one of the most heartbreaking tragedies in Indiana’s history, serving as a reminder of the importance of persistence in criminal investigations.

Richard Allen’s Sentencing and the Long Road to Justice for the Delphi Community

Richard Allen is set to appear before Judge Gull on December 20, 2024, for his sentencing hearing, where he faces a maximum sentence of 130 years in state prison. With Allen’s conviction, the Delphi community can begin its long-awaited healing process, though the road to recovery will be a gradual one.

This case has sparked broader conversations about justice, mental health, and the challenges within the criminal justice system. While the families of Abigail Williams and Liberty German have seen a measure of justice, their grief and loss remain ongoing, with the impact of the tragedy continuing to be felt by all who were affected.

Stay updated on more true crime stories and breaking news—check out our other articles for in-depth coverage and analysis!

• Celebrity News
• Family Matters
• For The Culture
• Mind & Soul
• Modern Womanhood
• Money Moves
• Ripped From The Headlines
• Trending Topics

Curious about more gripping true crime stories? Check out our ‘Ripped From The Headlines‘ section for shocking murder cases, high-profile trials, and more!