Eliza Fletcher’s Family Spares Her Killer from Death Sentence: A Heart-Wrenching Decision
In a devastating turn of events, the family of Eliza Fletcher—a devoted kindergarten teacher and beloved mother—has made the heart-wrenching decision to spare her killer, Cleotha Abston, from the death penalty.
This decision, revealed during a court hearing in Shelby County, Tennessee, comes after months of emotional turmoil following the tragic abduction and murder of Fletcher, 34, while she was out for a morning jog.
The Devastating Crime of Eliza Fletcher’s Murder

Eliza Fletcher was not just a teacher; she was a beacon of light in her community.
On September 2, 2022, her life was brutally taken when Abston, 40, abducted her in a shocking act of violence.
The details of the crime are chilling: Fletcher was beaten, shot, and left lifeless, sparking outrage and sorrow throughout the community.
Surveillance footage obtained by authorities captured a chilling scene: at around 4 a.m. on September 2, 2022, Eliza Fletcher was jogging along Central Avenue, near the University of Memphis campus, when tragedy struck.
The video shows a dark-colored SUV parked nearby, and as Fletcher approached, a figure emerged from the vehicle.
In a swift and terrifying move, Cleotha Abston chased Eliza Fletcher down, forcibly grabbing her and shoving her into the passenger side of the SUV.
Authorities later reported evidence indicating a violent struggle between Fletcher and her abductor, highlighting the desperate situation she faced.
Just days later, on September 5, Fletcher’s body was tragically discovered.
In the aftermath, Cleotha Abston was charged with first-degree murder and first-degree murder in the commission of kidnapping.
Before this, Cleotha Abston faced aggravated kidnapping and unlawful weapon charges against Alicia Franklin, raising concerns about Eliza Fletcher’s murder.
Remembering Eliza Fletcher

Eliza Fletcher was remembered fondly as a devoted mother and an inspiring educator at St. Mary’s Episcopal School, where she touched the lives of countless children.
As authorities pursued justice, the case garnered significant media attention, with many in the community demanding justice for Fletcher.
The Shelby County District Attorney’s Office initially sought the death penalty against Abston, viewing the crime as particularly heinous.
The Heart-Wrenching Decision to Spare Cleotha Abston’s Life
On October 28, 2024, the courtroom was filled with a palpable tension as District Attorney Steve Mulroy announced the plea deal that would change everything.
Fletcher’s family had come to a difficult yet poignant decision: they would support the plea deal that spared Abston from execution.
In a deeply emotional statement, District Attorney Steve Mulroy read a statement from Eliza Fletcher’s family in court.
They expressed their sorrow and outrage, questioning what could drive someone to commit such an atrocity.
In their statement read in court, Fletcher’s family expressed, “We have no idea what happened to you to turn you into someone so filled with a desire to hurt people,” addressing Abston directly.
Their words resonated in the courtroom, capturing the pain of their loss:
“Whatever it was, it does not excuse or explain what you have done. You have changed our lives forever, and nothing will ever be the same. Your actions were evil. There is no other word for it. You murdered Liza, even though she did nothing to deserve it.”
The Plea Deal That Spared Cleotha Abston’s Life
With the family’s support, Abston pleaded guilty to multiple charges, including first-degree aggravated kidnapping and tampering with evidence.
In exchange for his plea in the case of Eliza Fletcher, he was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole, building on the 80 years he was already serving for previous crimes against Alicia Franklin.
The significance of this plea deal is that it took the death penalty off the table, as Eliza Fletcher’s family agreed to spare his life.
This plea deal followed Cleotha Abston’s conviction for the kidnapping and rape of Alicia Franklin in 2021, where he agreed to the maximum sentence imposed by the judge.
He received 20 years for aggravated kidnapping, 40 years for aggravated rape, and 20 years for unlawful possession of a weapon.
The severity of these sentences reflects not only the gravity of his actions but also the community’s demand for justice, especially in light of the shocking circumstances surrounding Eliza Fletcher’s murder.
Alicia Franklin Lawsuit

The survivor of Abston’s earlier crime, Alicia Franklin, also stepped forward amidst the media frenzy surrounding Elizabeth Fletcher’s death.
She filed a lawsuit against the city of Memphis, claiming that police had neglected to investigate her own case thoroughly.
That lawsuit ultimately ended in dismissal in 2023, but it added another layer of complexity to Abston’s legal history.
Community Reactions to Eliza Fletcher’s Murder
The news of the plea deal sent ripples through the Memphis community, which has been grappling with issues of safety and violence.
Many residents expressed mixed feelings, grappling with the emotions surrounding Fletcher’s tragic death and the implications of the deal.
Some applauded the family’s decision as an act of grace, while others questioned whether justice had truly been served.
The Broader Impact of Eliza Fletcher’s Tragic Murder
This case highlights the complexities of justice, especially in cases of violence against women.
Fletcher’s legacy as a dedicated teacher and loving mother serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of compassion in the face of tragedy.
Her family’s choice to support the plea deal, while difficult, reflects a desire to focus on healing rather than revenge.
Moving Forward After the Eliza Fletcher Tragedy
As we reflect on the life and legacy of Eliza Fletcher, it is clear that her story transcends the tragedy of her death.
It invites us to engage in important conversations about safety, community support for victims, and the systemic issues surrounding violence.
Fletcher’s memory will continue to inspire us to advocate for a world free from violence and to cherish every moment with our loved ones.
By sharing this heart-wrenching story, we aim to foster dialogue about the complexities of human behavior and the essential need for compassion and understanding in our communities.
Eliza Fletcher’s life may have been tragically cut short, but her spirit lives on in the hearts of those she touched, urging us to strive for a better, safer world.
Shaneatra Jones Speaks
The Unimaginable Decision
When I read about the decision made by Eliza Fletcher’s family to spare the life of Cleotha Abston, I felt a heavy weight in my heart.
No family should ever have to face such an unimaginable choice after the brutal murder of their loved one.
Cleotha Abston is a murderer who deserves to be in prison for his heinous actions. Before he took the life of Eliza Fletcher in 2022, he had already kidnapped and raped Alicia Franklin in 2021.
Alicia Franklin took a courageous step in coming forward to say that if the city had not been negligent in releasing him after his heinous acts against her, he wouldn’t have had the opportunity to murder Eliza Fletcher.
While the family may have considered a plea deal, I can’t help but think that, if I were in their position, I wouldn’t have the strength to spare his life.
I commend them for their decision, but it’s a heavy burden to bear.
A Reminder of Women’s Safety
This tragedy is not just a story; it’s a harsh reminder of the dangers women face daily, especially when they step outside for a jog.
A recent publication by CBC emphasized the frightening reality of these dangers, highlighting that women everywhere must constantly plan every run and step for their safety.
For countless women who embrace running, an unsettling fear lurks beneath the surface—the fear of becoming the next victim, just like Eliza Fletcher, who tragically lost her life during a run.
Other names, such as Laken Hope Riley and Mollie Tibbetts, remind us that this threat is all too real.
We shouldn’t have to carry this burden, yet we do. As one runner said:
“The fault doesn’t lie with us; every woman deserves to feel safe.”
The Impact of Violence Against Women
Amplifying the Message Against Violence
As we remember Eliza Fletcher, we must amplify the critical message that violence against women must end. I am exhausted and suffocated by the fact that so many women are losing their lives due to domestic violence, murder, and other heinous acts. As a woman, I long for the safety of my own home, but that is often not the case.
Consider the heartbreaking stories of Tamika Huston, tragically murdered by her lover, and 16-year-old Aranda Briones, who was killed by someone she trusted in a revenge plot. Then there’s 18-year-old Andrea Camps-Lacayo, whose life was cut short over a sneaker transaction, and Lt. Eloilda “Ellie” Shea, murdered by her husband, who attempted to stage it as a suicide.
We also can not forget the recent tragic murder of Tamica Gant Lawrence in Bellflower, California, was murdered by her ex-boyfriend, Anthony Davidson, just hours after obtaining a restraining order against him.
We need to demand better protection from our local lawmakers and hold them accountable for ensuring the safety of women in our communities.
These stories highlight a troubling trend, and while the circumstances may differ, the alarming truth remains: violence against women is rampant, and we must take action to address this reality.
Eliza’s life was tragically cut short, and it’s heartbreaking to think that her story could have ended differently.
If Cleotha Abston had faced the consequences for his previous crime against another woman, perhaps Eliza’s life could have been spared.
A Call for Change
We need a society that listens to and protects women, ensuring that no one else has to endure the pain that Eliza’s family is experiencing right now.
Thank You For Your Support!
We appreciate you stopping by and hope you take some time to explore our website. Your support means the world to us and keeps us thriving. Please bear with us as we work to improve our site’s speed and enhance your experience. We’re excited to bring you top-quality content as we continue to grow!
Please Explore More Categories
- Celebrity News
- Family Matters
- For The Culture
- Mind & Soul
- Modern Womanhood
- Money Moves
- Ripped From The Headlines
- Trending Topics
About The Author
Discover more from Shaneatra Jones Speaks: The Inner Thoughts of A Modern Woman
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






