The controversial trial of Daniel Penny has reached its conclusion, with a Manhattan jury finding him not guilty of criminally negligent homicide in the death of Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old street artist, on a New York City subway.
This verdict, announced Monday, follows the dismissal of a more serious second-degree manslaughter charge last week. Judge Maxwell Wiley granted prosecutors’ request to drop the charge after jurors revealed they couldn’t agree on a verdict despite extended deliberations.
For Daniel Penny, a 26-year-old former Marine, the stakes were high—he faced up to four years in prison for criminally negligent homicide and up to 15 years for manslaughter.
Related|Judge Dismisses Manslaughter Charge in Daniel Penny Trial Following Jury Deadlock
Courtroom Reaction To Verdict
The not-guilty verdict was met with applause in the courtroom. Daniel Penny locked eyes with the jury, nodding in appreciation, and even smiled. In stark contrast, Jordan Neely’s father audibly expressed his frustration with expletives before being escorted out, CNN reported.
The jury deliberated for just over an hour on the negligent homicide charge. The manslaughter charge, however, had left them deadlocked after 16 hours of discussion, forcing another three-hour attempt before they again declared they couldn’t reach a consensus.
Jordan Neely’s father, heartbroken by the verdict, voiced his anguish in the courtroom, shouting expletives before being escorted out. CNN reported on the emotional scene, highlighting the deep pain and frustration felt by Jordan Neely’s family as the trial came to a close.
A Heartbreaking Subway Confrontation in New York

This case stems from a tragic subway confrontation on May 1, 2023. Jordan Neely, who struggled with homelessness, mental health issues, and substance abuse, boarded the train and began acting erratically. Witnesses reported him shouting that he was hungry, thirsty, and unbothered by the idea of dying.
Daniel Penny, seeing Jordan Neely’s outburst as a potential threat, grabbed him from behind in a chokehold. He brought Neely to the floor and restrained him for several minutes, as captured in a bystander’s video. By the time Penny released him, Neely was unresponsive and later pronounced dead.
Polarizing Opinions
Jordan Neely’s death ignited intense debate across the city. Some viewed Penny as a hero protecting fellow passengers, while others condemned his actions, calling them reckless and a reflection of deeper racial and societal injustices.
Black Lives Matter protesters added Jordan Neely’s name to their list of victims, staging demonstrations outside the courthouse. Meanwhile, Daniel Penny received praise from supporters who argued his intentions were to protect others.
Prosecutors portrayed Penny as careless, with Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran declaring, “The defendant used way too much force for way too long in way too reckless of a manner.”
Daniel Penny maintained he never intended harm, telling NYPD investigators, “I wasn’t trying to injure him. I’m just trying to keep him from hurting anybody else. He was threatening.”
The defense also questioned the medical examiner’s findings that the chokehold directly caused Jordan Neely’s death, suggesting the charges stemmed from a rush to judgment rather than sound medical science.
Jordan Neely’s Father Speaks Out
Outside the courthouse, Jordan Neely’s father, Andre Zachary, shared his heartbreak over the verdict, labeling the system “rigged.”
“I miss my son. My son didn’t have to go through this. I didn’t have to go through this either,” Zachary said. “It hurts, it really, really hurts.”
Family attorney Donte Mills echoed the disappointment, saying, “The jury in this case let us down.” He called for solidarity and urged those angered by the outcome to channel their energy into acts of kindness: “Go outside today and help one person. That’s how we beat the system. That’s how we turn this around.”
What Happened at the Trial
The trial, which began in late October, showcased a blend of witness testimony, video evidence, and expert opinions. Over 30 witnesses were called to testify by the prosecution, including Eric Gonzalez, a man who helped restrain Jordan Neely during the confrontation. Gonzalez testified that he advised Penny to loosen his grip, saying, “I’m going to grab his hands so you can let go.”
However, in video footage played during the trial, Gonzalez could also be heard saying Penny wasn’t squeezing Jordan Neely’s neck in the 51 seconds before releasing him. Gonzalez later admitted he initially lied to investigators out of fear of being blamed for the death.
A Marine Corps martial arts expert testified that Penny had been trained in chokeholds and was aware of their potential lethality. Subway riders who witnessed the incident described Neely’s behavior as terrifying and said they felt relief when Daniel Penny restrained him.
“Restraining him for the moment was a relief, but if he would have gotten up, he would have done what he would have done,” testified Caedryn Schrunk, a passenger, as reported by CNN.
The defense leaned on Daniel Penny’s military background and character witnesses to argue that his actions were intended to protect others. They also contested the medical examiner’s findings, presenting their own expert who cited multiple contributing factors to Jordan Neely’s death, including a sickling crisis tied to his sickle cell trait, a schizophrenic episode, the struggle, and K2 intoxication.
Civil Suit Filed
Even as Daniel Penny walked free from criminal charges, Jordan Neely’s father filed a civil lawsuit last week. The suit accuses Daniel Penny of assault, battery, and negligence, claiming his actions caused Jordan Neely’s death. The lawsuit doesn’t specify the monetary damages sought but keeps the case alive in the court of public opinion, AP News reported.
This trial has undoubtedly left its mark, igniting conversations about public safety, mental health, race, and the boundaries of self-defense. For some, it’s a story of a city grappling with chaos; for others, it’s yet another example of systemic inequality.
About The Author
Discover more from Shaneatra Jones Speaks: The Inner Thoughts of A Modern Woman
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






